Serving Westchester, Putnam & Fairfield Counties — Est. 2004☎ (914) 273-2353✉ Email Us
Planning

How Summer Programs Can (and Can't) Help Your College Application

Prestigious pre-college programs can be valuable — but the admissions benefit is often overstated. Here's how to think clearly about summer opportunities.

By College Planning of Westchester · Originally published January 22, 2025 · 7 min read

Students collaborating on a project during a summer academic program on a college campus
Every spring, the same question lands in our inbox: "Should my student apply to the [prestigious university] summer program?"
The short answer: it depends. The longer answer requires distinguishing between what summer programs actually do for an application and what families hope they'll do.

What Admissions Officers Actually Think of Summer Programs

Let's start with a candid observation. Admissions officers at selective colleges are well aware of the summer program landscape. Programs run by selective universities — Yale Young Global Scholars, Penn's Pre-College Program, Harvard Secondary School Program, and many others — are attended by thousands of students each year. Listing one on a college application registers as: this family could afford to send their student to a pre-college program.
That's not nothing. But it's a far cry from the impression some families have that attending these programs constitutes a meaningful admissions credential.
The programs themselves are academically excellent. Students consistently report that the coursework, the peers they meet, and the experience of living on a college campus are valuable — sometimes transformative. That value is real. It just isn't primarily an admissions strategy.

Summer Experiences That Do Matter to Admissions

The summers that actually differentiate applications are ones that demonstrate genuine initiative, sustained commitment, or unusual depth — not ones that demonstrate the ability to pay a program fee.
Examples of high-impact summers:
Research with a mentor. A student who cold-emailed a professor at a local university and spent the summer assisting in a lab — even doing unglamorous work — demonstrates initiative and intellectual curiosity in a way that a polished program cannot. The story is compelling because it required the student to make it happen.
Building something real. A student who spent the summer launching a small business, developing an app, organizing a community program, or completing a creative project has a concrete artifact to discuss. The achievement is theirs.
Meaningful work experience. Internships, jobs, and apprenticeships — especially in fields the student wants to pursue — show colleges that the student has tested their interests against reality. A student interested in medicine who spent a summer volunteering in a hospital is telling a more credible story than one who attended a pre-med summer camp.
Sustained service. Ongoing volunteer commitment — not a two-week trip, but genuine involvement over months — signals character and community engagement.
Skill development with depth. A musician who spent the summer in intensive training, a writer who completed a manuscript, an athlete who dedicated the summer to a meaningful competition circuit — depth in a pursuit the student is already known for strengthens the narrative.

The Role of Cost

This is worth stating plainly: many of the most impressive summer activities cost very little. Research emails are free. Starting a blog, a newsletter, or a small business requires initiative, not tuition. Many local nonprofits actively welcome teenage volunteers who show up reliably.
Meanwhile, some of the most expensive summer programs produce applications that, from a purely strategic standpoint, look similar to thousands of others. There is no correlation between what a family spends on summer and the quality of the application that results.

How to Think About This Decision

When evaluating any summer opportunity — paid program, internship, self-directed project, or anything else — we encourage families to ask three questions:
  1. Will my student be genuinely engaged? Interest that is forced for a college application almost always reads as such. If the student isn't actually excited, the essay and interview answers will reflect that.
  1. Is this the best use of this time given what the student is already doing? A student with a strong research focus gains more from a summer research opportunity than from a leadership program. A student with no clear direction might benefit from the exposure a broader program provides.
  1. What story does this tell — and is it a story only this student can tell? The more the activity can be summarized as "attended a program," the less differentiating it is. The more it reflects the student's own choices and initiative, the stronger it reads.

Our Recommendation

Encourage your student to do something this summer that genuinely interests them. The best summer activities have a natural narrative that extends into the application — they become the evidence that the essays describe.
If a prestigious program genuinely excites your student and your family can afford it without strain, by all means consider it. But don't let the brand name of a summer program substitute for the harder work of helping your student develop a real story about who they are and what they care about.
That story is worth far more.